eBay announced a "proactive fraud reduction" initiative on Monday. On the one hand, eBay is expanding the number of listings that are being delayed as eBay reviews them for possible counterfeit items. On the other hand, sellers will be notified during the listing process through a pop-up warning if the listing will be delayed, and once the listing is visible through search and browse, it will appear at the top of search results when sorted by Newly Listed.
As an update to the story, eBay did get back to us on the question about listings that been held for review prior to this week's policy change that had not received top exposure on Newly Listed search results. I asked whether eBay would provide any recompense for sellers of those items for getting less exposure than they normally would have. eBay spokesperson Nichola Sharpe replied via email:
"No, eBay does not charge for listing time by the hour or by the day, so we do not refund in this situation. We certainly work to minimize any impact to our sellers, however, by ensuring that listings are indexed as soon as possible. To improve this for our sellers, we've made the change to ensure listings become visible at the top of Browse listings pages and in "newly listed" sort option as soon as they are made visible in Search, regardless of the time when they were listed."
In terms of targeting listings of items prone to counterfeiting, it seems inevitable that some babies will be thrown out with the bathwater, as the expression goes. It reminds me of email filters that prevent legitimate emails from getting through in an attempt to eliminate spam. Nevertheless, it's understandably frustrating to sellers who feel their listings should not be targeted.
I believe there is good news in this announcement from eBay - if it works as described, sellers will be aware of delays as they list, and their items will receive top exposure on Newly Listed results.
eBay has been doing this listing delay sham for a good 3 Years on eBay Motors, and looking at my site http://www.ebaymotorssucks.com you can see just how effective it has been!
All the scammers do is list a simple legitimate looking auction, let it pass through pre-search screening, then revise it after it is search-able. Many motors professionals suspect all eBay is doing is delaying listings so we think they are looking for fraud. Now they come up with this same line of bull as a measure to curb the fraud on the core site!
Here is a screen shot of how the scammers do it. http://www.ebaymotorssucks.com/images/na...
These are the facts.. No mater how eBay tries to spin it!
I would have too agree with tht e above statement. Consumers/users simply browsing by category etc will be able to see and fall victim to the bogus listings.
This new "Proactive Fraud Reduction" is "pretty funny and ridiculous", although that was not the 1st catch phrase to come ton mind.
All this will really do is to prevent folks from finding and reporting (or DOCUMENTING) the fraud.
This does absolutely NOTHING to protect consumers, only to shield the fraud. This is just another in a clearly continuing series of actions which appear to be purposefully designed to conceal or obfuscate fraud, and which clearly harm or place at greater risk, the consumers.
Fraud which ebaY profits from.
Coupled with ebaYs other fraud ensuring measures, such as the "SMI" plan, it is time to increase consumer awareness (again)
An example of how the new policy works... The listings appear as newly listed. Note that the time encode in the screencaps is very close.
But upon opening the listing, weee see that it has in fact run for quite some time, which, can and will be found by persons browsing by category, if not more ways.
All the measure serves is to conceal the fraud and harm the consumer. PERIOD.
(oops, except to further illustrate the level of outright DISHONESTY!!!)
Scrolling down the page a bit, we see a very familiar email address,
Montana.Investments@gmail.com
An addy which has been used time and time again, and which was featured in ream after ream of listings yesterday, may even still or again be there now, and NO DOUBT will be there again, soon.
You need not be a dental floss tycoon to see that the hackers OWN ebaY!!! (yippie aye oh! Ky-Ay!!!)
Oh, and BTW, I have listings captured which showed within mere minutes of their actual listing times, I will post those later.
What was that Romanian phrase for, (roughly) "This one will walk by", or something very similar?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I still do not find words like HACK, or Hijack even mentioned, although there are a couple soundoffs about the new "policy".
I have a hard time believeing that no one is sounding off about that.
It does seem a shame, to me anyway, that the #1 online auction related publication is not giving these recent, very serious, continuing, persistant, ongoing events/problems some proper level of reasonable, objective coverage.
So much for whatever delays they were talking about anyway. (I am sure everyone realizes by now that ebay has a LOT of bungling buffoons, so NEVER believe anything from them. NEVER... EVER!)
Here is a fresh screencap, made just one minute or so before I post this.